
"History" has two meanings. Genuine history should be understood as the
unfolding of human experience--everything that has happened to people. The other
meaning of the word is as recorded history--the portion of the human experience that
historians and others have selected to write down and consecrate. This process inevitably
yields an incomplete view of the past. But an incomplete view can be a representative view,
rather than an inaccurate one. How well the incomplete view of the past that written history
gives us reflects the actual history lived by people depends upon the basis that has been chosen
for inclusion or exclusion in written history.
This course will explore the early history of human beings by attempting to address
three areas that historians have often overlooked or shortchanged. The first is the fact that the
human species consists of two sexes and history cannot be properly understood if we look
solely at the activities of only one of those sexes. Until quite recently, history was seen as if
it were "his-story." It is only in the last quarter century that historians have begun to give
serious consideration to women and the parts they have played in history. In this course we
will strive always to remember that history must be herstory, as well.
But while the fundamental error of deleting half of humanity from history has been
partially corrected, two other omissions, both related to the ignoring of women, continue to be
the general practice. One of these is the assumption that there are no basic, innate traits or
predispositions in humans--that there is no such thing as human nature. The underlying
supposition, which has been with us since John Locke in the seventeenth century, is that we are
born as "blank slates" upon which culture and experience write a script. This assumption
allows historians to ignore the biological nature of the beings that they study.
The third area to which historians have usually given too little attention is "pre-history."
A sharp division between archeology/anthropology and history has left most historians as
ignorant of the early development of the people they study as they are of the biological natures
of their subjects. Understandably reluctant to draw many conclusions about life in times for
which we have no written records, historians have for the most part acted as if human history
began about the same time that writing was invented--shortly before 3000 B.C. If human
history cannot be properly understood without an acquaintance with the innate biological
predispositions with which evolution left us, neither can it be accurately fathomed without some
knowledge of the effects of the monumental alterations in the human social environment that
occurred during the approximately five thousand years between the invention of agriculture and
the invention of writing.
It is easy to appreciate the hesitation of historians in saying much about the period
before writing. The methodological difficulties involved in considering such periods are
enormous. But there were people living in these vast eras, and they had lives--there is a
"prehistoric history." Learning about this history is very difficult, and conclusions we reach
about it must be classified as highly tentative and in some cases even speculative. It involves
borrowing from many other disciplines, including biology, archeology, anthropology, and the
study of religion and mythology. But historians believe that "what is past is prologue," and
human history in the time when there was no or little writing has had important effects on the
history that followed.
It makes little sense to try to examine the upper stories of a tall building without looking
at the building's foundation and lower stories. Human history has become a very tall structure.
Its foundation is human nature and the lower stories upon which the upper stories rest are "pre-history." Those lower stories are composed of "her stories" as well as "his stories." The
objective of this course is to explore the foundation and lower stories of the human experience.
That exploration will be completely interdisciplinary, involving biology, archeology, paleo-anthropology, mythology, religion, philosophy, art, literature, drama, and politics, all of which
we shall endeavor to blend into a wider understanding of the early stages of human history.
Roughly the first half of the course will be devoted to the generally neglected bases of
history in the Paleolithic, Neolithic and Bronze Ages--the evolution of the human "biogram"
(innate traits), the way of life of hominids and early human collector-hunters, the invention of
agriculture and the profound effects this transformation of the way humans live (the
Agricultural Mega-Revolution) had on such areas as sex roles, worldviews, religion, and
science.
The second half of the course will examine the more traditional period of the ancient
world, down through the first centuries of the Christian era. Our chief concentration will be
on southwest Asia and northeast Africa (the regions often termed the "Near East" or the
"Middle East"), India, China, and southern Europe, especially Greece and Rome. The theme
that we will follow through these cultures is the way in which various developments in them
constituted attempts to deal with the disruption of the balance between human nature and the
social environment that was caused by the new ways of life created by agriculture. Religion
will be a particular focus of this line of inquiry.
The ideal of a liberal arts education includes more than the expansion of knowledge,
although that is certainly an important part of such an education. Core courses at Millsaps vary
widely in content, but they are all designed to help students develop certain skills and abilities.
This course seeks to assist students in cultivating several core abilities and themes. As the later
section on Course Requirements details, the course places a heavy emphasis on the growth of
communication skills. Students will have frequent writing assignments, will have numerous
chances to participate in oral communication in class, and will work together in small groups.
There will be many opportunities for students to ripen their reasoning abilities. Many
ideas that will come up in the class will be unfamiliar and run counter to beliefs with which
many students have grown up. Some of the positions taken by authors that we read in the
course are likely to upset--perhaps even anger--some students. This will provide an opening
to analyze arguments made by writers, reflect on them, and respond to them critically. Some
of the readings have been selected because they are controversial and will give students a
chance to see that it is possible for them to question and criticize "authorities," provided that
they can develop a rational basis for criticism.
Historical consciousness is central to the course. Students will see that while humans
share a basic biological nature and people in "pre-historic" times were essentially the same as
we are, when and where people live have great impacts on how they live and what they think
and believe. In this course we will be dealing with people whose ways of life, beliefs and
values are as far removed from those that are prevalent in the modern world as it is possible
to find. This will give students an opportunity to reflect on their own values and beliefs and
ask themselves why they believe and value the things that they do.
Because the course deals with such different societies, including those that existed
before writing and even before agriculture, as well as with early societies in South and East
Asia, students will vividly experience some of the variety of cultural possibilities that humans
have developed in different times and places. Aesthetic judgment will be enhanced by
examining artistic works from "pre-historic" and ancient cultures and questioning the criteria
we use to react to creative works.
The central focus of the course is on sex and gender, how they differ, and how they
have shaped human experience and religious beliefs throughout history. Another major focus
of the course is on the enormous ways in which the development of agriculture altered the
environment, physical as well as social.
Robert S. McElvaine is Elizabeth Chisholm Professor of
Arts and Letters and Chair of the Department of History
at Millsaps.
Erin Keller, a sophomore from Henderson, Tennessee,
will be assisting in the course.
A variety of teaching methods will be used in the course, to accommodate
different learning styles: full class discussions, small group discussions, lectures,
primary and secondary readings, films, journals, free-writing, brief papers, and a longer
paper that will be revised throughout the semester.
It is the instructors' intention that there will be no tests in this course. (Tests may be added if it becomes apparent that a significant fraction of the class is not
keeping up with the reading and other assignments. We very much hope that this will
not be necessary.) Instead, students will be evaluated on the basis of four other major
criteria: an extensive journal, a series of short papers, a longer paper that will be
worked on throughout the semester, and participation in class discussions. A small part
of the grade will be based on a series of map quizzes that will be given throughout the
course.
Journals
The journal is the basis of the rest of the course. It will lead into the long paper,
provide ideas for the short papers, and have a two-way relationship with the
discussions, both preparing students for class discussions and providing a vehicle for
further reactions to points that have been discussed in class.
A journal is a diary of your thought processes. After a session of reading, after
a class discussion, or after a film, you should sit down and simply start writing about
your most dominant or curious impressions, just as in a diary you might review or
comment upon the day's events. By its nature, a journal may ramble, because you may
have no idea what you are going to say when you begin writing. The act of getting
words and ideas on the page will help you discover what your most important concerns
are in the course.
In your journals, you are asked to interact with the readings and with points that
come up in class. Ask questions about what you read, hear and see, and ponder (in
writing) possible answers. Journal entries should demonstrate both that you have read
the assignment and that you are thinking about what you read. Refer to a substantial
number of specific points, using quotations where helpful; question these points and
comment on them. In addition to comments on the readings, journals should also
contain comments on points that come up in class lectures and discussions and reactions
to films, works of art, and other sorts of texts that are used in the class.
Although the instructors will, in fact, be grading your journals, what you write
is primarily for your own use, both during the course and in the future. You will want
to keep your journals from this course, since they will constitute a record of your
thoughts during what we hope will prove to be a very interesting period of your lives.
You need not worry about shifting topics, contradicting yourself, losing sense or being
unconvincing. Correctness of language and problems of spelling should not even cross
your mind (unless, of course, you want them to be a concern). Just put down your first
reactions and explore them until you have worked them out fully.
The journal will work for you only if you make it a habit. If you wait for the
spirit to move you before you pull out the journal, many of you will not use it very
much. The best way to establish real discipline is quite simply to set aside 15 minutes
or so after each reading session, class, or other activity. You may not always get done
in that time, but at least you will know that it is a part of your routine.
Doing your journal in the proper spirit will make you a better reader and thinker;
it will also prepare you to participate more fully in class discussion and enable you to
raise issues that really concern you.
The Journal Assignment
* Obtain a notebook that you use only as a journal for this course. This should
be separate from the place where you take notes in class.
* Date each entry and keep up with the assignments right from the start.
* Begin your journal immediately, with entries on this week's readings, films, and discussions.
* Write an entry for most of the reading assignments, including several each for
the whole books we are reading and entries for several class discussions. You
should write several (a minimum of three) journal entries each week.
Journals will be collected for comments and grading several times during the
semester. The purpose of the journal is to give the student an opportunity for frequent
interaction with the ideas of the course. This means that it is essential that entries be
made on a regular basis, at the time the reading is done.
Since your journal is to be used, among other purposes, to help stimulate class
discussion, students are required to bring their journals with them to each class.
In order to ensure that they are being kept up to date, the days on which they will
be collected for review by the instructors will not be announced ahead of time.
Your journal will count for 30% of your grade in the course (more than any other
single part of the course), so give it the attention it deserves.
Short Papers
Short (2-3 typed pages) papers will be assigned at various times during the
semester. These will ask for student reaction to points raised in class and to readings
and other sorts of texts.
Long Paper
The paper is not a research project. It is intended rather as an opportunity to
draw together ideas from different readings and discussions to create a personal
assessment of the ideas discussed in the course. Students may choose any approach to
the topic, but should consult frequently with the instructors. Journal entries will provide
much of the raw material for the paper, but it is expected that the paper will be done
with great care and much revision. The final version should be approximately 10 to 12
typed pages.
First drafts of papers will be due on Tuesday, October 28. Second drafts will
be due on Tuesday, November 18. Final papers will be submitted on Tuesday,
December 9.
Discussions
Attendance at all class meetings is expected. It is also expected that reading
assignments will be completed before the class meeting for which they are assigned.
A diversity of viewpoints is welcomed in class discussions. You should bring up in
class any questions you have from the readings.
In addition to full class discussions, we will frequently break up into small groups
to discuss particular questions and ideas that have come up in readings or class. Mr.
McElvaine and Ms. Keller will circulate among the groups to listen to the discussions
and participate in them on a limited basis, but they will consist primarily of students in
the group talking with each other. Students will be assigned to a small group early in
the course. Membership in these groups will be changed at least once during the
course.
Map Quizzes
In order to begin to remedy for members of this class the serious deficiency in
geographic knowledge that is so widespread in the United States, a series of map
quizzes will be given throughout the semester. Students will be given maps of different
continents prior to the quiz on that continent, so that they can study, using the
Hammond Historical Atlas of the World, and improve their basic geographic knowledge.
Journal 30%
Short Papers 25%
Long Paper 20%
Discussion 20%
Map Quizzes 5%
The Millsaps Honor Code is in full effect in this course. Because the course
makes use of collaborative learning for some assignments, it is necessary that students
understand from the outset what is acceptable in terms of working together. Students
will work together in small groups and discuss matters that arise in the course, including
readings, films, and points that come up in class. It is completely acceptable for
students to use ideas that come out of these discussions when they write in their journals
and when they write their papers. The actual writing of all papers (except the group
paper to be done after the meetings on September 30) and journals, however, is to be
an individual activity. Students should not provide assistance to each other in writing
journals or individual papers. It is more than acceptable, though, to use assistance from
the Writing Center in writing papers. Students are strongly urged to write drafts of
their papers early enough that they can take them to the Writing Center for help before
they write the final version to be handed in.
Richard Wrangham and Dale Peterson, Demonic Males.
Margaret Ehrenberg, Women in Prehistory.
Kevin Reilly, ed., Readings in World Civilizations, Vol I, Third Edition.
Euripides, The Bacchae, translated by Michael Cacoyannis.
Hammond Historical Atlas of the World.
Course Reader for IDS 1200-05.
Plus additional readings to be handed out in class.
Date, Topic and Reading
W Aug 27 Organizational Meeting
Th Aug 28 What is History -- And Does Biology Have Anything
to do with It?
READING: Carefully read this entire syllabus, &.
handouts from the New York Times.
Tu Sep 2 Evolution and the Development of Hominids
FILM (to be shown in class):
In Search of Human Origins, Part 1.
READING: Reilly, pp. xvii-19.
W Sep 3 In Search of Human Origins
FILM (to be shown in class):
In Search of Human Origins, Part 2.
READING: Wrangham & Peterson, pp. 1-82.
Th Sep 4 Can We Learn About Humans from Apes?
READING: Wrangham & Peterson, pp. 83-152.
Tu Sep 9 Are Men Naturally Violent?
READING: Wrangham & Peterson, pp. 153-258.
W Sep 10 "Pre-History" -- And "Pre-Herstory"
READING: Ehrenberg, 38-76.
Th Sep 11 Does Evolution Cause the Sexes to
Behave Differently?
Sound
READING: Excerpt from Robert Wright, The
Moral Animal, in Course Reader.
Tu Sep 16 Roots: The Invention of Horticulture and
How It Transformed Human Life
Sound.
READING: Ehrenberg, 77-107;
Reilly, 21-25.
W Sep 17 Invention is the Mother of Necessity:
The Agricultural Mega-Revolution and What It
Did to Male and Female Roles
Sound.
READING: Reilly, 26-30.
Th Sep 18 Discussion.
Tu Sep 23 The Bronze Age in Mesopotamia
READING: Reilly, 37-48;
Three Mesopotamian Myths (handout).
W Sep 24 Does Sex Matter?
FILM (to be shown in class):
Gender: The Enduring Paradox.
Th Sep 25 Discussion.
Tu Sep 30 What Are We to Make of All This?
Students will meet with their small groups to discuss the ideas and interpretations that
have arisen so far in the class and what they think of them. Each group will produce a
short collaborative paper summarizing their reactions to the course so far and addressing
specific questions that will be given to them by the instructors.
W Oct 1 Science Imitates Life: The "Conception Misconception" and Creation
Stories
READING: Excerpts from the Enuma Elish, Genesis, Hesiod's Theogeny and Works and Days, and Ovid's Metamorphoses, in Course Reader.
Th Oct 2 "Tell Me All Your Thoughts on God":
The Triumph of a Male God and What It Has Meant
Sound
READING: Excerpt from Aeschylus, Eumenides, in Course
Reader.
FILM (to be shown in class):
Eumenides
Tu Oct 7 Discussion of the Conception Misconception & the Triumph of a Male
God
W Oct 8 Discussion

Th Oct 9 Egyptian Civilization
READING: Reilly, 30-37;
Excerpts from "The Instruction of Ptahhotep," "The
Dispute Between a Man and His Ba," "The Instruction of
Any," and The Book of the Dead, in Course Reader, and
"The Hymn to Aten" (handout).
Tu Oct 14 Hebrew Civilization and Religion
READING: Reilly, 105, 108-114;
Excerpts from Deuteronomy and Isaiah,
in Course Reader; excerpts from Exodus
and Job, (handouts).
W Oct 15 Introduction to India
FILM (to be shown in class):
Legacy: India: The Empire of the Spirit.
Th Oct 16 Indian Civilization
READING: Reilly, 49-57.
FALL BREAK
W Oct 22 Religion in India: Hinduism
READING: Reilly, 134-139.
Th Oct 23 Religion in India: Buddhism
READING: Reilly, 139-149.
Tu Oct 28 Early Chinese Civilization
READING: Reilly, 57-60.
W Oct 29 Discussion: Chinese Society & Thought
Th Oct 30 Confucianism and Taoism
READING: Reilly, 150-161.
Tu Nov 4 "Verbal Mounting"
W Nov 5 Discussion
Th Nov 6 Minoan Civilization and Early Greece
Sound
READING: Ehrenberg, 108-174.
Reilly, 63-65;
Excerpt from The Iliad (handout).
Tu Nov 11 Sparta and Athens
READING: Reilly, 65-73.
W Nov 12 Women and Men in Classical Greece
READING: Euripides, The Bacchae.
Th Nov 13 Greek Thought
READING: Reilly, 73-83;
Plato, excerpt from the Symposium (handout);
Aristotle, excerpts from The Generation of Animals, in Course Reader; Aristotle,
excerpt from Nichomachean Ethics (handout).
Tu Nov 18 Alexander and the Hellenistic World
READING: Reilly, 84-86.
W Nov 19 Rome -- From Republic to Empire
READING: Reilly, 86-104.
Th Nov 20 Women, Men, and Society in Rome
READING: Excerpts from Cicero, Virgil, and Horace,
and Juvenal, "Against Women" (handouts).
Tu Nov 25 Eastern Religions and Christianity
READING: Excerpts from Matthew in Course Reader; Reilly, 114-125.
Tu Dec 2 She Is Risen? -- Women & Men in Christianity
READING: Reilly, 125-133;
Excerpts from Corinthians & Ephesians in Course Reader.
W Dec 3 Discussion
Th Dec 4 Constantine and the Masculinization of Christianity
READING: Excerpts from Tertullian,
On the Apparel of Women, in Course Reader.
Tu Dec 9 Catching Up and Reflecting
Sound
The class will discuss and reflect upon the ideas discussed throughout the course and the ways in which they reacted to those ideas.