Wednesday, February 21, 2001
Read His Lips: He's No Wimp the Younger
George W. Bush wasted no time in confronting the question that
haunted his father's presidency. Whatever other reasons he may have had
for last week's bombing of Iraq, the new president clearly wanted to show
that he was prepared to act like a man.
His father, who was so plagued by masculinity questions, did not wait
for the election to be decided before he asserted the younger Bush's
manhood. When, a few days after the election, ABC reporter Sam Donaldson
asked the former president how his son was reacting to the roller coaster
of the Florida vote, George the elder replied: "Like a man, with great
With this brief proclamation, the elder Bush indicated his own
insecurities, and also something that lies beneath much of politics
Just look at the 2000 election. It featured a Democratic candidate who
hired a feminist to advise him on how to look like an "alpha male,"
opposing a Republican candidate whose father had been tormented by
insinuations that he was a "wimp." President Bush the Elder had tried to
show his manhood prior to the Persian Gulf War by proudly declaring about
Saddam Hussein: "If we get into an armed situation, he's going to get his
A few years earlier, Garry Trudeau had begun calling the senior Bush a
wimp in his cartoon "Doonesbury." Trudeau also said Bush had placed his
manhood in a blind trust. Cartoonist Pat Oliphant added to Bush's agony
by portraying him carrying a purse over his shoulder, wearing high heels
and a skirt. And Newsweek magazine had a cover story on Bush's "wimp
It seems clear that a desire to liberate himself from such unmanly
images played a role in former President Bush's eagerness to have a war
to liberate Kuwait. "You're talking to the wimp," a still-seething Bush
said to reporters 2 1/2 months after the end of the Persian Gulf War.
Such anxieties are by no means confined to the Bush family. Insecure
masculinity has, in fact, been a major force in history. Sexually
insecure men often seek validation of their manhood by pursuing power.
"But he was a man!" a trembling Richard M. Nixon affirmed of Theodore
Roosevelt as Nixon concluded his rambling talk to the White House staff
at the time of his resignation in 1974. There can be little doubt that
the disgraced president had himself in mind as he referred to this
Insecure masculinity was a major motivation for several other 20th
century presidents, from Teddy Roosevelt at the century's beginning to
Bill Clinton at its end. The Republican Roosevelt is a prime example. One
reason for Roosevelt's concern about proving his manhood was his feeling
of shame that his father had paid for a substitute to fight in his place
during the Civil War. Roosevelt spoke of almost everything in sexual
terms. He said war was a necessary arena for the display of "manly
virtues" and frequently referred to adversaries as "eunuchs" or
"impotent." And it does not take a Freudian imagination to understand why
Roosevelt used the "big stick" as his metaphor for military might.
Similar anxieties appear to have driven John F. Kennedy and his
disciple Clinton to try to show their manhood by treating women as
disposable playthings. And it could be argued that Lyndon B. Johnson took
the nation into a war that he knew would be disastrous partly out of a
desire to prove his manhood. "There's not anything that'll destroy you as
quick as pulling out," Johnson told Sen. Richard Russell in 1964.
"They'll forgive you anything except being weak. We've got to conduct
ourselves like men." As had Roosevelt, Johnson often described male
opponents of his war policy by names that indicated they were like women.
Although sexual insecurity often motivates men to seek power, it is
not a prerequisite for achieving high political position. Sometimes men
who seem to be relatively secure in their sexuality manage to rise to the
top. Jimmy Carter, for example, confined his lusting to his heart and has
been noted for his ability to reconcile conflicting parties without
having to resort to macho tactics.
Unfortunately, though, political leaders who have been intent on
proving to themselves and others that they fit the accepted definition of
manhood as the polar opposite of womanhood have been more common. Last
week, President Bush may have fired a preemptive strike in Iraq to head
off any suggestion that his middle initial stands for "wimp."
- - -
Robert S. Mcelvaine, a Professor of History at Millsaps College, Is the Author of "Eve's Seed: Biology, the Sexes and the Course of History," Just Published by Mcgraw-hill
Copyright 2000 Los Angeles Times